The Other Boleyn GirlI have to admit, my knowledge of European history is lacking. I spent most of my historical studies in high school and college focused on American history. I did take one European history class from Coach Henry, but in his defense it's difficult to teach history when you know nothing about history. With that in mind I will say that I'm not sure of the Hollywood vs. History argument in regards to The Other Boleyn Girl but it makes for a good story even if they took a significant amount of artistic license.
I was a little worried before walking into the theater since Hollywood has a bad habit of using period pieces as a crutch, placing too much time and money into fancy costumes and ornate set decoration. But after watching TOBG I have to say that I was pleased they chose to focus on the story of two sisters living in a world where pretty daughters could be dealt like playing cards to influence socio-economic status and policy.
Like Ibsen's A Dolls House before it, The Other Boleyn Girl gets a little preachy in spots with it's womens lib message but backs away from the cliff that would have relegated it to Lifetime Movie of the Week status. As family ambition pushes the boundaries of decency the story takes on an almost Shakespearian tone as every decision backfires and the world begins to spiral out of control.
Scarlett Johnanson is a nice fit as the sweet and pure Mary Boleyn who desires a simple life in the country and Eric Bana is underrated as an actor over all, but he didn't have much to work with as a weak minded Henry VIII. Natalie Portman's, Anne Boleyn falls a little short. First off I didn't feel she was as sinister and manipulative as required. It also wasn't quite believable that Henry would fall so hard and so quick. She simply wasn't the Helen of Troy I was expecting. Like Helen, Anne should have the face that launched a thousand ships and thrust countries into war over her beauty. I just wasn't convinced that Henry would spend that much time thinking with his penis and tear his country apart with vast and wide reaching political decisions all based on the whims of a young girl. Not to say it didn't happen.
Over all The Other Boleyn Girl is a good film just not a great romantic epic. But for those who enjoy history about kings and queens, a nice soap-opera like period piece, or just a good cat fight then it's entertaining and I think most will enjoy it. It opens today.








