Since our new poll features a uniform discussion, I thought it would be fun to give my rundown on the best ACC Helmet designs. After all the helmet is what the entire uniform is built on and it's the first thing we identify with. This is just my opinion based completely on my personal "feelings" along with my professional perspective as a graphic designer.
Let me say that I believe the helmet should be a number of things. Aside from the obvious of good graphic design and good representation of school colors. It should also be original and it should illustrate the school, team or mascot in a unique way. There is also something to be said for simplicity, and tradition.
#12 - Wake ForestAlthough the school colors of Black and Gold are represented nicely, I get the feeling they didn't even try. Does WF decal even qualify as a logo? Not in my eyes. Sure there is simplicity, but without a storied tradition to back it up it comes off as lazy. Sorry Wake, I like you, but you get last place for what feels like a complete lack of effort. I preferred the 90's helmet a little more.
#11 - DukeDuke keeps trying and trying. In the past several years it seems every time I watch them play I see a new helmet design. OK, maybe I'm overstating that. I do think the stylized "D" is better than the helmets that actually said "Duke" on the side, but I did like the dark blue helmets better. The black face mask is completely out of place and I'd recommend trying white or blue. It's getting better, but still not quite there.
#10 - North CarolinaThe NC logo has always been nice, although it feels "fat." If they would commit to slimming it down a little it would play much better. Personally NC will always lose points in my book for having a baby blue football helmet. You call it "Carolina Blue" if you like, but I just can't believe you'll strike fear into the hearts of the opposing team with this color blue. I would love to see them play with some ideas featuring the darker blue and use the "Carolina Blue" as an accent. Yes, I know Carolina traditionalists are throwing items at their computer monitors, I just blasphemed in the House of Butch.
#9 - MiamiNice use of color and I will give the Canes points for originality. But Miami's helmet has always come with one big question, What's with the big "U?" Does it mean something? Is there historical significance I'm missing? Sorry Miami, you're not the only
University. If I didn't know college football I would probably ask , "Is that the helmet of the University of Utah?"
#8 - Boston CollegeThe Eagles get most of their points for simplicity and the tradition to follow it up. It would almost be a shame at this point to plaster a large flying eagle on the side and break that tradition, but that also means you could never try anything different.
#7 - North Carolina StateI think this is probably the best NC State helmet they've had. It's much better than the horrible diamond shaped NCS logo of its predecessor. With that being said, NC State has one of the more unique mascots in college football, "The Wolfpack," so it's kind of a shame the helmet design doesn't use that to its advantage.
#6 - Virginia TechI'm not really sure how I feel about VaTech's helmet; part of me thinks it made it to number 6 by default. The Hokies have one of the more unique color combos in college football. Is it an off-shade of maroon, or a McDonald's "Grimace" purple? Yes, Ronald's buddy, the talking eggplant. Plus a hue of orange that can only be found in the 72 box of Crayola Crayons, you know, the one with the built in sharpener. The VT logo says what it needs to say while the uni-tone helmet and mask feel complete. So, I guess in the middle is where it belongs.
#5- MarylandI gotta say I've never been a fan of writing your name or your mascots name on your helmet, which pushed Maryland to number 5 in my book. That being said, I think it works fairly well. Terrapin is unusual so "The Terps" get points for being unique and using that uniqueness to illustrate something different about the team. If it makes those watching a Maryland football game for the first time ask, "What's a Terp?" then it's a good design. I'm just grateful it doesn't say "Fear the Turtle."
#4 - ClemsonClemson has always had one of the better helmets in the ACC. It fills all the requirements: it stands alone, it's easily recognizable, it's a nice use of the school colors and best of all, it represents the school, mascot or team with the design. The Tigers get points for using the purple but downplaying it at the same time. The white paw provides a good contrast against the orange backdrop. In the end Clemson loses points to drop it to number 4 due to the fact that this paw print design is used by half the high schools in the country.
#3 - Georgia TechYes, I have made a valid attempt to be objective and there is a chance that my love for seeing the Ga Tech gold helmet shining in the sun helped push it this high on the list. In my defense, it's a great helmet, and the Ramblin' Wreck does get points for tradition. It's also the best of what I call the "name logo" helmets. Those logos that are built off the schools name. Examples include, VaTech, North Carolina, Duke, Wake Forest, and NC State. Maryland and Clemson would be examples of what I refer to as the "mascot logo" helmets. To be fair, I admit that it doesn't do the best job in promoting Tech's color scheme which is White, Gold and Blue. NOT Black. The White throwback helmets from 2006 did a perfect job of addressing this problem by using Tech's navy blue in the correct way.
#2 - VirginiaThe Cavaliers helmet design hits correctly on all points. Good design, good color usage, good representation of team with the logo. I'm not a huge fan of the stylized stripes and I would like a little more contrast, but overall it's a nice design.
#1 - Florida State
Historically, the Seminoles have had a collection of the worst and almost comical helmets, but not this time. Like Clemson, Virginia and Maryland, this design fills all the requirements of a good football helmet. Great use of color (in the way I wish GaTech's helmet did), great representative logo, simple in idea yet graphically aware. Also there is a chance that my love for gold helmets helped push it to the top.
Like I said, just my opinion. Leave comments, let me know what you think. Next time I'll take a stab at SEC helmets. Yes, I do watch the SEC and yes, I do pull for some of their teams (although, the SEC wasn't part of the wedding vows).